Home plate umpire Stu Scheurwater issued his first ejection of the 2026 MLB regular season on September 20, tossing Athletics manager Mark Kotsay during the bottom of the fourth inning against the Cleveland Guardians.
The controversy erupted with one out and a runner on base in a tight 1-0 contest. Guardians batter Jo Adell hit a 1-1 changeup from A’s pitcher Jack Perkins back to the mound. Perkins fielded the ball and attempted to throw Adell out at first base, but the ball was not caught by first baseman Tommy White. Replays clearly indicated that batter-runner Adell stepped onto the infield grass while running to first base, directly interfering with the fielder’s ability to field the throw.
Under Official Baseball Rule 5.09(a)(11), a batter is out when running the last half of the distance from home to first base if they run inside the foul line on the infield grass and interfere with the fielder taking the throw at first base. Despite the violation, the umpires allowed play to continue without calling runner’s lane interference (RLI). Kotsay vigorously protested the missed call, leading Scheurwater to send the manager to an early shower. The Quality of Call was evaluated as incorrect (QOCN).
This marked Kotsay’s third ejection of 2026 and his first since August 18. It was Scheurwater’s first ejection since September 20, 2025. League-wide, this incident stands as the 119th ejection report of the 2026 MLB season and the 70th manager toss of the year.
The missed call proved critical in a defensive duel, as the Guardians maintained their 1-0 advantage to secure the victory over the Athletics.